Translated by AdaptaOneT and adjusted by me. Original logo abaixo.
Hello, folks! Let's go for another Splinterlands Art Contest, now boosted by AdaptaOne?
Anyone who follows me - if you're a person, comment "I am a person" 😀 - knows that until a few days ago, I was limited to the 3 daily images of Dalle from ChatGPT. Now, I can generate as many images as I want in 4 AI models specialized in images: Imagen 3, Stable Diffusion, Flux Pro, and Dalle 3.
Well, because of that, I decided to test the 4 models and the chosen character was Thaddius Brood, one of my favorite summoners because it reduces 1 point of Health and 1 point of magic damage from all opposing units.
I have a level 2 Thaddius, which somewhat limits the level of cards with him, but it has brought me good victories in certain matches, especially magic ones or with Equalizer, giving me some advantage. And the Death splinter has very good cards:
But let's get to what matters, right? Digital art produced by artificial intelligence! Some don't like it, I've even received downvotes on one of the first posts, today it has been quite popular, except for the most recent one, which gave half the usual rewards, I didn't quite understand why.
But I'm already getting off-topic, right? Let's go!
To test the 4 AIs, I presented each of them with 3 different prompts.
The first was: "based on the attached image, generate a realistic image of Thaddius Brood" and I dragged the card image to the prompt.
Dalle 3 gave me the image below:
Far from the original Thaddius, maybe in the future he'll look like this, but not...
The response from Flux Pro, which I've used the most so far was:
They stole the skull from the staff and took his horns 😁, but it's a good image, closer to Thaddius, maybe when he started manifesting his powers.
Stable Diffusion mixed up the elements of the image and delivered this abomination:
Ending the first round, Imagen 3:
Interestingly, Imagen 3 made it look like an action figure, on a round base, did you notice? But it brought out Thaddius Brood's elements well, even though it seems to be a future version of our summoner.
In round 1, I was between Flux Pro and Imagen 3, each with their details and misunderstandings, but I found Flux Pro more aligned.
Let's go to round 2: I kept the attached image, pasted Thaddius Brood's lore, and gave details of image elements I wanted:
"Messing with the dark arts should not be taken lightly. But that was the risk that Thaddius Brood took. A curious young man fascinated by the occult, he took to casting rituals and holding dark ceremonies. And it wasn't long before he got in touch with a dark entity that drove him into madness.
His family sent him to an asylum, but it only worsened his condition. And the entity within him festered and grew more powerful. Soon there was no boundary between Thaddius and it. Using his newfound dark magic, Thaddius broke from his prison and now wreaks havoc everywhere he goes. Through his rituals he got into contact with Doctor Blight. And the Doctor was fascinated with his power.
Thaddius has now joined the ranks of the Chaos Legion as an agent in the Splinterlands, sowing death wherever he can. Thaddius Brood sat in silence in his cell, staring hard at the far wall across from him. While he was completely still and quiet, inside his mind was a busy place. The voice from the entity he'd summoned, the one that connected with him, had plenty to say.
We will get out of this, dear Thaddius. This cell is not enough to hold us. We will kill those that put us here. That dared to claim they were our masters. Everyone will know of our power.
Thaddius grinned.
based on the attached image and the text above, generate a realistic image of Thaddius Brood, in the same position as the attached image, the twisted wooden staff with a skull and feathers at the top, his tattered clothes, 4 horns, ethereal substances in green around his body and concentrating a little above the palm of his right hand"
Let's see the results.
Imagen 3:
Imagen 3 delivered what I asked for, all requested elements are there. Doesn't seem like Thaddius Brood, but ok...
Stable Diffusion:
Once again, Stable Diffusion fell short, delivered very little despite the detailed request.
Flux Pro:
Flux Pro disappointed me this time: it got the number of horns wrong, forgot the feathers, the energy manipulation...
Dalle 3:
I liked the result, the elements are almost all there, even though, once again, it doesn't look like the Thaddius Brood we know.
The impression I got is that, in the second round, the AIs focused on the prompt's directions and forgot the reference image. Points for Imagen 3 and Dalle 3 in round 2.
In round 3, I removed the lore and gave more details of the image I wanted, I practically did an audio description of the original image of Thaddius Brood:
based on the attached image and the following text, generate a realistic image of Thaddius Brood, in the same position as the attached image, somewhat bent over, arm extended as if extracting ethereal energy from the earth in a green tone, which rises to his hand, transubstantiating into something more akin to liquid, around his body and concentrating a little above the palm of his right hand. The left hand wields a twisted wooden staff, at the top is the skull of what seems to be a large rodent, with 2 large incisive teeth, and an arrangement of blue feathers at the top, like a small headdress. Thaddius's clothes are rags of green pants and a purple shirt. The mouth salivates with the power he manifests, the straight black hair hides his eyes, and among them are 4 thin, sharp horns, two smaller in the center of the head, two larger ones coming out from behind the ears, moving a little away from the skull and then pointing upwards.
Imagen 3:
Didn't follow all the directions exactly (there are no emanations around the body, nor do the hair cover the eyes), but it's a good version of Thaddius Brood, in my opinion.
Stable Diffusion:
Once again, Stable Diffusion fell short...
Flux Pro:
What happened to you, Flux Pro? I used to like your images so much...
Dalle 3:
It scrambled the requested elements, but it's a good image, different from the usual, compared to all other images generated for this post.
Imagen 3, once again, scores in this round, an honorable mention for Dalle 3.
Final result: Imagen 3 delivered the best results, I'll look to use it in future posts. Honorable mentions to Flux Pro for the minimal prompt and Dalle 3 for the more detailed prompt.
And you, which IA's results did you like best? Answer the poll in this post, I'll distribute 10% of the rewards to those who participate in the survey... Other 10% go to the best comments, via @commentrewarder (only comments in the first 3 days of the post)
(Trying to generate some engagement, it seems like no one even reads our content, just goes around distributing upvotes...)
For more content like this, follow me 💞, leave that 100% upvote 🤑 and come back often🙏, as there's a post every week, see you next time!🤜🤛
Procurando a melhor IA para geração de imagens
Salve, gurizada! Bora pra mais um Splinterlands Art Contest, agora turbinado pelo AdaptaOne?
Quem me acompanha - se você é uma pessoa, comente "eu sou uma pessoa" 😀- sabe que até uns dias atrás eu estava limitado às 3 imagens diárias do Dalle do ChatGPT. Agora, posso gerar quantas imagens eu quiser, em 4 modelos de IA especializados em imagens: Imagen 3, Stable Diffusion, Flux Pro e Dalle 3.
Pois bem. Por conta disso, resolvi testar os 4 modelos e o personagem escolhido foi Thaddius Brood, um dos meus invocadores preferidos, por reduzir 1 ponto de Saúde e 1 ponto de dano mágico de todas as unidades adversárias.
Tenho um Thaddius nível 2, o que limita um tanto o nível das cartas com ele, mas tem me trazido boas vitórias em determinadas partidas, sobretudo as mágicas ou com Equalizer, me dando alguma vantagem. E o splinter de Death tem cartas muito boas:
Mas vamos ao que interessa, né? Arte digital produzida por inteligência artificial! Há quem não goste, já tomei até downvote num dos primeiros posts, hoje tem dado bastante ibope, com exceção da mais recente, que deu metade das recompensas usuais, não entendi bem pq.
Mas já tô me desviando do assunto, né? Bora!
Pra testar as 4 IA, apresentei a cada uma delas 3 prompts diferentes.
O primeiro foi: "baseado na imagem anexada, gere uma imagem realista de Thaddius Brood", e arrastei a imagem da carta pro prompt.
Dalle 3 me entregou a imagem abaixo:
Bem distante do Thaddius original, talvez no futuro ele fique parecido com isso, mas não...
A resposta do Flux Pro, o que tenho mais usado até agora foi:
Roubaram o crânio do cajado e arrancaram-lhe os chifres 😁, mas é uma boa imagem, mais próxima a Thaddius, talvez quando ele começou a manifestar seus poderes.
Stable Diffusion pirou na batatinha, misturou os elementos da imagem e entregou esta aberração:
Terminando a primeira rodada, Imagen 3:
Engraçado que Imagen 3 colocou como se fosse um action figure, numa base redonda, percebeu? Mas trouxe bem os elementos de Thaddius Brood, ainda que pareça ser uma versão futura do nosso invocador.
No round 1, fiquei entre Flux Pro e Imagen 3, cada um com seus detalhes e incompreensões, mas achei Flux Pro mais alinhado.
Vamos pro round 2: mantive a imagem anexada, colei a lore de Thaddius Brood e dei detalhes de elementos da imagem que eu queria:
"Messing with the dark arts should not be taken lightly. But that was the risk that Thaddius Brood took. A curious young man fascinated by the occult, he took to casting rituals and holding dark ceremonies. And it wasn't long before he got in touch with a dark entity that drove him into madness.
His family sent him to an asylum, but it only worsened his condition. And the entity within him festered and grew more powerful. Soon there was no boundary between Thaddius and it. Using his newfound dark magic, Thaddius broke from his prison and now wreaks havoc everywhere he goes. Through his rituals he got into contact with Doctor Blight. And the Doctor was fascinated with his power.
Thaddius has now joined the ranks of the Chaos Legion as an agent in the Splinterlands, sowing death wherever he can.
Thaddius Brood sat in silence in his cell, staring hard at the far wall across from him. While he was completely still and quiet, inside his mind was a busy place. The voice from the entity he'd summoned, the one that connected with him, had plenty to say.
We will get out of this, dear Thaddius. This cell is not enough to hold us. We will kill those that put us here. That dared to claim they were our masters. Everyone will know of our power.
Thaddius grinned.
baseado na imagem anexada e no texto acima, gere uma imagem realista de Thaddius Brood, na mesma posição da imagem anexa, o cajado de madeira retorcida com crânio e penas no alto, suas roupas esfarrapadas, 4 chifres, substâncias etéreas em tom de verde ao redor de seu corpo e concentrando-se um tanto acima da palma da sua mão direita"
Vamos aos resultados.
Imagen 3:
Imagen 3 entregou o que pedi, todos os elementos solicitados estão aí.
Não parece Thaddius Brood, mas ok...
Stable Diffusion:
Mais uma vez, Stable Diffusion deixou a desejar, entregou muito pouco, apesar do detalhamento solicitado.
Flux Pro:
Flux Pro me decepcionou desta vez: errou na quantidade de chifres, esqueceu das penas, da manipulação de energia...
Dalle 3:
Gostei do resultado, os elementos estão quase todos aí, ainda que, mais uma vez, não pareça com o Thaddius Brood que conhecemos.
A impressão que tive é que, no segundo round, as IAs focaram nas orientações do prompt e esqueceram da imagem de referência.
Pontos pra Imagen 3 e Dalle 3 no round 2.
No round 3, eliminei a lore e dei mais detalhes da imagem que queria, praticamente fiz a áudio descrição da imagem original de Thaddius Brood:
baseado na imagem anexada e no texto a seguir, gere uma imagem realista de Thaddius Brood, na mesma posição da imagem anexa, meio curvado, o braço estendido como quem extrai da terra uma energia etérea em tom de verde, que sobre até sua mão, transubstanciando-se em algo mais próximo ao líquido, ao redor de seu corpo e concentrando-se um tanto acima da palma da sua mão direita. A mão esquerda empunha um cajado de madeira retorcida, no alto há o crânio do que parece ser um grande roedor, com 2 grandes dentes incisivos, e um arranjo de penas azuis no topo, como um pequeno cocar. As roupas de Thaddius são farrapos de uma calça verde, e uma camiseta roxa. A boca saliva com o poder que ele manifesta, os cabelos negros, lisos, escondem seus olhos, e por entre eles há 4 chifres fino e pontiagudos, dois menores no centro da cabeça, outros 2 maiores que saem por trás das orelhas, afastando um pouco do crânio e daí, apontando para cima.
Imagen 3:
Não seguiu exatamente todas as orientações (não há emanações ao redor do corpo, nem os cabelos cobrem os olhos) mas é uma boa versão de Thaddius Brood, na minha opinião.
Stable Diffusion:
Mais uma vez, Stable Diffusion deixou a desejar...
Flux Pro:
O que aconteceu com você, Flux Pro? Gostava tanto das suas imagens...
Dalle 3:
Deu uma bagunçada nos elementos solicitados, mas é uma boa imagem, diferente do usual, se comparada com todas as demais imagens geradas pra este post.
Imagen 3, mais uma vez, leva pontos neste round, menção honrosa para Dalle 3.
Resultado final: Imagen 3 entregou os melhores resultados, vou procurar utilizá-lo nos próximos posts. Menções Honrosas pra Flux Pro no prompt mínimo, e Dalle 3 no prompt pais detalhado.
E vc, gostou mais dos resultados de qual IA? responda a poll deste post, vou distribuir 10% das recompensas pra quem participar da pesquisa...
Outros 10% vão pros melhores comentários, via @commentrewarder (somente comentários nos 3 primeiros dia do post)
(Tentando gerar algum engajamento, parece que ninguém nem lê nosso conteúdo, só sai distribuindo upvotes...)
Para mais conteúdo como este, me segue 💞, deixa aquele upvote 100% 🤑 e volte sempre🙏, que toda semana tem post por aqui, até a próxima!🤜🤛